Does the treatment of minority doctors by the UK regulator demonstrate Institutional Racism? Perspective from BAME doctors

Main Article Content

Mr Vipin Zamvar MS FRCS FRCTh

Abstract

In June 2021, an Employment Tribunal accepted the claim from the complainant that the UK regulator, the General Medical Council may have discriminated against a doctor based on his race, ethnicity or religion in their processes and outcomes. [1] This is perhaps the first time that such a claim of discrimination based on race, ethnicity or religion has been passed in the UK, hence this is hailed as a ‘landmark judgement’. It is not the first time that doctors have claimed that GMC and its processes demonstrate institutional racism. [2] The Kline report described the existence of ‘In groups and out groups’ determined by qualifications (including by country and within the UK by medical school) and ethnicity (including within BME populations). They found that members of ingroups can receive favourable treatment and those in out-groups are at risk of bias and stereotyping.[3] Amitabha Banerjee, wrote in the BMJ, that overt and covert racism within the medical profession is rarely talked about but existed then, and still, unfortunately, exists now, albeit to a lesser extent, to this day.[4] The case of Hadiza Bawa-Garba, a Paediatric trainee who was struck off the register by the GMC on negligence and then subsequently restored demonstrated discrimination in the processes, as the duty White consultant did not face any disciplinary process. Complaints are more likely to be against BAME doctors, and when they proceed to the regulator or the law courts, they are more likely to lead to more serious punitive measures and guilty verdicts. [5–7]


The debate on whether GMC’s processes were unfair, discriminatory and racist started in 1996.[8] However, even in 2003, the GMC council has debated the issues of institutional racism and expressed its commitment to fairness [9] but little progress has been made even 2 decades later. In its submission to William’s review in 2018, BAPIO had recommended that the review must advise the GMC and the NHS to acknowledge the existence and impact of racial discrimination and make concerted efforts to improve this image nationally and abroad. [10] About the differential outcomes for doctors from minority ethnic backgrounds in examinations, assessments, and recruitment, the GMC is committed to ensuring that medical education and training pathways are valid, fair and justified. [11]


The world including the NHS is changing. The Care Quality Commission (CQC) has issued an open statement, together with the NHS Race and Health Observatory, Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) and the GMC, calling on healthcare leaders to ensure that health and care staff across the country are protected from racism or any other form of discrimination. The statement demonstrates a collective commitment to work together to tackle racism, bias and inequalities within the healthcare system, calling on healthcare leaders to ensure that policies and processes are fair, inclusive and in line with the Equality Act 2010.


The GMC sets “ambitious” targets to address specific areas within medical the profession to address entrenched bias and racial discrimination, which it believes requires “sustained focus and for healthcare regulators to be aligned on this commitment”.  Dame Clare Marx, the chairperson of the GMC UK, reiterated her commitment to creating robust processes which were fair, transparent and just in dealing with all doctors, offer speedy resolutions/ outcomes of cases, offer sensitivity and support to doctors under investigation. She committed the GMC to facilitate change across the system. [12] The NHS has been working to close this gap by adopting national targets in formal disciplinary investigations between White and BAME staff.[13] There is more visibility of the work of overseas doctors and issues of racism are being more openly debated. There has been progress, but if we want to attract the best doctors in the world to the NHS, we have to create an environment where those doctors will be treated fairly and without discrimination. In his Blog following a recent meeting with the GMC in Scotland on equality, diversity and inclusion, Vipin Zamvar explores the feedback he has received from his colleagues and issues a wake-up call to the profession.

Article Details

How to Cite
Zamvar, V. (2021). Does the treatment of minority doctors by the UK regulator demonstrate Institutional Racism? Perspective from BAME doctors. Sushruta Journal of Health Policy & Opinion, 14(2), 1-6. https://doi.org/10.38192/14.2.9
Section
Blogs
Author Biography

Mr Vipin Zamvar MS FRCS FRCTh, Royal Infirmary Edinburgh, Scotland, UK

Consultant Cardiothoracic Surgeon

Chair, BAPIO Scotland

 

References

1 Final-Press-Release-17.06.21_.pdf. https://www.matrixlaw.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Final-Press-Release-17.06.21_.pdf (accessed 19 Jun 2021).
2 Moghal N. The GMC can learn from its institutional racism. BMJ 2013;346:f3226. doi:10.1136/bmj.f3226
3 Fair to refer? https://www.gmc-uk.org/about/what-we-do-and-why/data-and-research/research-and-insight-archive/fair-to-refer (accessed 19 Jun 2021).
4 Amitava Banerjee: Institutional racism is still a major problem in the NHS. The BMJ. 2018.https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2018/01/31/amitava-banerjee-institutional-racism-is-still-a-major-problem-in-the-nhs/ (accessed 19 Jun 2021).
5 Singhal P, Pandya B. Beyond BAWA-GARBA: Sushruta Journal of Health Policy & Opinion 2018;11:20–1. doi:10.38192/11.1.8
6 The Bawa-Garba case | The BMJ. https://www.bmj.com/bawa-garba (accessed 21 Jan 2020).
7 Bawa-Garba case has left profession shaken and stirred | The BMJ. https://www.bmj.com/content/360/bmj.k456 (accessed 5 Jun 2021).
8 Godlee F. The GMC, racism, and complaints against doctors. BMJ 1996;312:1314–5. doi:10.1136/bmj.312.7042.1314
9 S H. No closer to understanding racial bias, admits GMC. BMJ 2003;326:518–518.https://europepmc.org/article/PMC/1169282 (accessed 19 Jun 2021).
10 BAPIO’s Written Submission to the Williams’ Review. BAPIO | British Association of Physicians of Indian Origin. 2018.https://www.bapio.co.uk/bapios-submission-to-the-williams-review-bme-doctors-the-state-of-bias-in-the-nhs-and-impact-of-differential-sanctions-by-the-gmc/ (accessed 19 Jun 2021).
11 Improving outcomes for minority ethnic and overseas-trained doctors: perspectives from Medical Royal Colleges. Improving medical education and practice across the UK. 2017.https://gmcuk.wordpress.com/2017/06/19/improving-outcomes-for-minority-ethnic-and-overseas-trained-doctors-perspectives-from-medical-royal-colleges/ (accessed 19 Jun 2021).
12 Dame Clare Marx’s message to the profession. https://www.gmc-uk.org/news/news-archive/dame-clare-marxs-message-to-the-profession (accessed 19 Jun 2021).
13 NHS England and NHS Improvement Midlands » Eliminating racism and bias in disciplinaries. https://www.england.nhs.uk/midlands/wrei/eliminating-racism-and-bias-in-disciplinaries/ (accessed 19 Jun 2021).
14 Dyer C. Covid-19: Intensive care consultant has suspension cut short to help fight pandemic. BMJ 2020;:m2040. doi:10.1136/bmj.m2040
15 Does a Narrow Definition of Medical Professionalism lead to Systemic Bias and Differential Outcomes? | Sushruta Journal of Health Policy & Opinion. http://sushrutajnl.net/index.php/sushruta/article/view/113 https://doi.org/10.38192/14.1.13 (accessed 8 Mar 2021).
16 sitecore\jpjadwat@rcseng.ac.uk. We will put diversity at the heart of our strategy. Royal College of Surgeons. https://www.rcseng.ac.uk/about-the-rcs/about-our-mission/diversity-review-2021/ (accessed 19 Jun 2021).